Vehicle Data Hub

2009 MINI Cooper S Clubman problems

Owners have filed 64 complaints with NHTSA about the 2009 MINI Cooper S Clubman. Engine is the most reported problem area, at 48% of complaints. After that come drivetrain & axles (16%) and electrical system (12%).

At a glance

Complaints
64 filed with NHTSA
Most reported
Engine 48% of complaints
Crashes and fires
0 and 3
Injuries and deaths
0 and 0
Typical mileage
47,000 miles 58 complaints with mileage

Source: NHTSA owner complaints

Where the complaints are

Share of this model year's complaints by the part of the car involved. One complaint can name more than one part, so the shares can add up to more than 100%.

  • Engine 48%
  • Drivetrain & axles 16%
  • Electrical system 13%
  • Air bags 9%
  • Brakes 3%
  • Fuel system 2%
  • Lighting 2%
  • Seat belts 2%
  • Body & structure 2%
  • Transmission 2%

When problems show up

Complaints by mileage, 2009 MINI Cooper S Clubman Complaints by odometer reading in 20,000-mile steps. The median is about 47,000 miles. 0k to 20k miles: 2 complaints 20k to 40k miles: 21 complaints 40k to 60k miles: 19 complaints 60k to 80k miles: 7 complaints 80k to 100k miles: 5 complaints 100k to 120k miles: 2 complaints 120k to 140k miles: 1 complaints 140k to 160k miles: 1 complaints 160k to 180k miles: 0 complaints 180k to 200k miles: 0 complaints 200k+ miles: 0 complaints 040k80k120k160k200k miles Typical: 47,000 miles
Based on 58 complaints that include mileage. 72% were reported before 60,000 miles. The amber marker shows the median: half of these complaints happened before that mileage.
View the numbers
MileageComplaints
0k to 20k miles2
20k to 40k miles21
40k to 60k miles19
60k to 80k miles7
80k to 100k miles5
100k to 120k miles2
120k to 140k miles1
140k to 160k miles1
160k to 180k miles0
180k to 200k miles0
200k+ miles0

What the data shows

Among the 58 complaints that report mileage, the typical (median) problem appeared at about 47,000 miles. For engine specifically, the median reported mileage is about 49,000 miles (29 complaints with mileage).

Safety-related details: 3 complaints mention a fire. Its complaints are less severe on average than those of 81% of model years in our database.

It is also covered by 2 safety recall campaigns.

What owners wrote

A few complaints as filed, shortened and with personal details removed. The first ones are among the most serious reports for this model year; the rest are typical.

I parked my 2009 mini clubman after driving about 10 miles to the grocery store round trip and unloaded groceries, went back out to the car and it was smoking white smoke. Flames started shooting up from the engine over the windshield and it progressed from there. The smoke turned black all windows were blown out, front tires melted and blown and the car was declared an obvious total loss. It caught our home on fire and has caused more than $50,000 worth of damage. Please correct this problem.

Reported at 23,000 miles, June 2010 Fire

After driving to work for 30 minutes, I parked my car. I thought I smelled something as I walked away, so I stopped an looked, but I did not see anything. Five minutes after walking into my building, someone told me my car was on fire. The first witness to see something (a co-worker) said he saw something on fire drop from the bottom of the car. When I ran outside, the car was putting off a significant amount of smoke. We tried to use a fire extinguisher, to no end, and within minutes we were seeing flames.

Reported at 38,500 miles, September 2011 Fire

2009 mini clubman s... Timing chain needs replaced at 51000. 1000 miles out of warranty. Mini will not take responsibility. This is poor engineering and even poorer lack of accountability from mini for a known, documented, and very frequent problem.

Reported at 51,000 miles, December 2011

I live where the weather gets into the teens regularly this time of year. My car started making a weird noise when I started in one morning. Then when I tried to drive it, it had no power. I took it in and had to have the throttle body and new intake manifold put in for the cost of over $1100. I was told by the service technician that they have only had to do this repair on mini's that live in cold climates and that it was no fault of mine. However there is no recall on this defect and I'm curious as to why?

Reported at 58,500 miles, February 2013

Other model years of the Cooper S Clubman

  • 2024
  • 2023
  • 2022
  • 2021
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2014
  • 2013
  • 2012
  • 2011
  • 2010
  • 2009
  • 2008