Vehicle Data Hub

2009 Toyota 4RUNNER problems

The 2009 Toyota 4RUNNER has 33 complaints on file with NHTSA. The largest share (21%) concerns transmission. Next are electrical system (12%) and engine (12%).

At a glance

Complaints
33 filed with NHTSA
Most reported
Transmission 21% of complaints
Crashes and fires
8 and 1
Injuries and deaths
1 and 0
Typical mileage
23,000 miles 31 complaints with mileage

Source: NHTSA owner complaints

Where the complaints are

Share of this model year's complaints by the part of the car involved. One complaint can name more than one part, so the shares can add up to more than 100%.

  • Transmission 21%
  • Electrical system 12%
  • Engine 12%
  • Drivetrain & axles 9%
  • Body & structure 9%
  • Air bags 6%
  • Fuel system 6%
  • Steering 6%
  • Suspension 6%
  • Cruise control 3%

When problems show up

Complaints by mileage, 2009 Toyota 4RUNNER Complaints by odometer reading in 20,000-mile steps. The median is about 23,000 miles. 0k to 20k miles: 13 complaints 20k to 40k miles: 4 complaints 40k to 60k miles: 0 complaints 60k to 80k miles: 7 complaints 80k to 100k miles: 0 complaints 100k to 120k miles: 2 complaints 120k to 140k miles: 3 complaints 140k to 160k miles: 1 complaints 160k to 180k miles: 0 complaints 180k to 200k miles: 0 complaints 200k+ miles: 1 complaints 040k80k120k160k200k miles Typical: 23,000 miles
Based on 31 complaints that include mileage. 55% were reported before 60,000 miles. The amber marker shows the median: half of these complaints happened before that mileage.
View the numbers
MileageComplaints
0k to 20k miles13
20k to 40k miles4
40k to 60k miles0
60k to 80k miles7
80k to 100k miles0
100k to 120k miles2
120k to 140k miles3
140k to 160k miles1
160k to 180k miles0
180k to 200k miles0
200k+ miles1

What the data shows

Of the 31 complaints that include odometer readings, half describe a problem before roughly 23,000 miles.

Safety-related details: 8 complaints mention a crash; 1 complaint mentions a fire; 1 injury reported. Its complaints are more severe on average than those of 83% of model years in our database.

Looking only at complaints filed within five years of the model year (so older and newer years are comparable), the 2009 ranks 30th most-complained-about out of 35 model years of the Toyota 4RUNNER with enough data (23 complaints in that window). It is also covered by 6 safety recall campaigns.

What owners wrote

A few complaints as filed, shortened and with personal details removed. The first ones are among the most serious reports for this model year; the rest are typical.

I was driving in the left/fast lane on a toll road when another vehicle who was speeding in excess of 55MPH entering the toll road crossing and cutting off the other lanes of traffic running into me on the passenger side forcing me into the concrete wall/barrier head on. His vehicle swung into again into my passenger rear side then bounced off. I was stunned, in shock, unable to exit on my side and didn't see it coming.

Reported at 11,261 miles, September 2009 CrashInjury

My granddaughter was driving a 2009 that I bought her for graduation in may 2010. In june 2010 she and some friends were driving and a fire started in the console area. There were flames and smoke. They stopped the car, went up to someone's house and got water to pour into the car and put out the fire out. If they hadn't been quick thinking, the car would be toast. Also, if they had wrecked and could not get out of the car, they would have had severe burns or death.

Reported at 23,000 miles, June 2010 Fire

When my wife stepped on the gas to pull into a parking spot,the 4runner just lurched forward into a fence. Luckily no one was in front of the 4runner. The bumper and fence was damaged. She is now very scared to drive the 4runner.

Reported at 67,237 miles, August 2013 Crash

2009 4 runner transmission: same as other complaints about slipping and lag time in engaging into gear at low speeds (like when slowing down to make turns or go over speed bumps). Obviously not shifting correctly and is a safety issue when turning across traffic and the vehicle does not respond properly when the accelerator is depressed. Toyota needs to investigate this as it looks like a recurring problem for this year and a safety issue.

Reported at 20,000 miles, August 2010

The contact owns a 2009 Toyota 4Runner. The contact stated while pulling out of a driveway, the contact observed a grinding noise coming from the front end of the vehicle and the steering wheel violently yanked to the right. Additionally, the contact stated that when the brake pedal was depressed, the vehicle pulled to the left inadvertently. The vehicle was stopped and inspected. The contact observed that the front passenger’s side tire was dangling by the rocker arm and the subframe.

Reported at 114,000 miles, June 2024

Other model years of the 4RUNNER

Best and worst years for the Toyota 4RUNNER